Wrong person reply

What to send when they say “not me”

A "not me" reply is the start of a conversation with someone else. Four short emails, whether they give you a name, give you none, or just say no.

By

Dimitrije Jimmy Rešetar

·

Updated

TYPE

Reply handling

SITUATION

Not me, wrong person

PERSONA

Any B2B buyer

SHAPE

One email, four variations

When to use it

Use this when someone replies to your cold email to say it isn’t theirs. It happens in every campaign, and it’s one of the more useful replies you’ll get, because they read the email and they’re telling you where it should have gone.

People who see a genuine match usually tell you who to contact. Even when they don’t, the reply tells you the company is worth reaching and the person isn’t. Every “not me” deserves an answer. In practice not everyone sends one, but if you need opportunities, each of these replies is worth answering.

The three replies you’ll get

The reply

What you do

“You should talk to Adam.”

Write to Adam on the spot, and say who sent you (variation A).

“It’s not my job, I’m the wrong person.”

Thank them and ask who the right person is (variation B), or look up two likely colleagues and ask which one (variation C).

“No.” No name, nothing else.

Thank them in one line, find the right person yourself, and write to them (variation D).

If the no is to the offer rather than to being the right person, it’s a no. Thank them and stop.

THE COPY

Send it the same day the reply comes in, while the person who replied still remembers your email. Every new email ends with your signature and a one-line opt-out (“If this isn’t relevant, just let me know and I won’t reach out again.”).

When you write to someone new, answer the reply that sent you there too, in a line, like “Thanks, I’ll write to Adam” or “Thanks for letting me know.” It costs nothing, and it’s the difference between a person and a sequence.

B and C are both for a “not me” with no name. Use C when your data tool shows you who the likely people are, since picking between two names is easier than thinking of one, and B when it doesn’t.

SUBJECT

B and C are replies in their thread. A and D start a new thread to a new person, with the subject your sequence used, for example renewals.

The email

Same day

Variation A: they named someone
Hi {{firstName}}, [Their colleague's first name] suggested I get in touch with you about [the area] at {{companyName}}. [One line on why you were writing, as it applies to their job.] Is [the problem] something you're working on right now?
Variation A: they named someone
Hi {{firstName}}, [Their colleague's first name] suggested I get in touch with you about [the area] at {{companyName}}. [One line on why you were writing, as it applies to their job.] Is [the problem] something you're working on right now?
Variation B: no name, so you ask for one
Thanks for letting me know, {{firstName}}. Who would be the right person to talk to about [the area] at {{companyName}}? A name is plenty, I'll take it from there.
Variation B: no name, so you ask for one
Thanks for letting me know, {{firstName}}. Who would be the right person to talk to about [the area] at {{companyName}}? A name is plenty, I'll take it from there.
Variation C: no name, so you offer two
Hi {{firstName}}, thanks for letting me know. Should I check in with [first colleague's first name] or [second colleague's first name] about [the area] instead?
Variation C: no name, so you offer two
Hi {{firstName}}, thanks for letting me know. Should I check in with [first colleague's first name] or [second colleague's first name] about [the area] instead?
Variation D: a flat no, so you found the person yourself
Hi {{firstName}}, Is [the problem, as their team lives it] something you're working on at {{companyName}} right now? From what I can see, [the area] sits with you, so you're the person I should have written to first. [One line on what you do about it.]
Variation D: a flat no, so you found the person yourself
Hi {{firstName}}, Is [the problem, as their team lives it] something you're working on at {{companyName}} right now? From what I can see, [the area] sits with you, so you're the person I should have written to first. [One line on what you do about it.]

Want this running
on your account?

We run outbound for B2B companies and build the system underneath it, which you own. First campaigns live in two weeks.

What to personalize

Line

Weak

Strong

Who sent you

“I was told to contact you.”

“Maria suggested I get in touch with you about renewals at {{companyName}}.”

Why you were writing

“We offer a range of solutions.”

“We help customer success teams catch the accounts that go quiet before renewal.”

Asking for a name

“Can you forward this to the right person?”

“Who would be the right person to talk to about renewals? A name is plenty.”

Offering two names

“Is there anyone else on your team I could talk to?”

“Should I check in with Mike or Amy about renewals instead?”

The person you found

“I’m reaching out to the decision maker.”

“From what I can see, renewals sit with you, so you’re the person I should have written to first.”

Use the name exactly as they wrote it, and the area in the words of the person who replied. If they said “that’s Adam in RevOps”, the email to Adam is about RevOps, not the title you guessed.

Why it works

  • A name is the warmest lead the sequence produced. Someone at their own company pointed you to them. Saying so in the first line gets the email read.

  • The same day keeps the thread alive. The person who replied remembers your email today. Next week, if Adam asks them about it, they won’t.

  • One easy question gets the name. “Who would be the right person?” takes five seconds to answer, and “a name is plenty” tells them they don’t need to forward anything or explain.

  • Two names are easier still. Picking one of two colleagues takes less thought than coming up with a name, and it shows you did the looking before you asked.

  • A flat no isn’t asked twice. Someone who said no once won’t enjoy being asked for a favour. Finding the right person yourself respects that and still gets you to them.

  • Owning the mistake reads as a person. “You’re the person I should have written to first” is honest, and it’s an easier email to reply to than one pretending it’s your first try.

Common mistakes

Leaving the reply unanswered

A “not me” with a name is a referral, and no answer means you dropped it.

Forwarding the original email to the new person

It was written for someone else. Write a new one to them, in their terms.

“Can you introduce me?”

It turns their helpful reply into a job. Ask for a name, and do the writing yourself.

Offering a list of names

Two is a choice, and five is homework. Pick the two closest to the area by role.

Dropping the new person into the full sequence

They came with a name attached. Write to them as a person first, and only follow up if they don’t reply.

Naming someone who didn’t send you

“Sam told me to contact you” when Sam only said no is the kind of thing that gets checked.

Asking twice

One “who should I talk to?” is fine. If it gets no answer, or the reply was a flat no, find the person yourself.

Finding the person yourself

  • Start with the area, not the title. Look for who owns the problem you solve, which isn’t always the most senior person.

  • Search the company in your data tool, Apollo or another, by the roles closest to the area, and check on LinkedIn that they’re still there. For variation C, keep the two closest.

  • Verify the address before it sends. A new contact is a new address, and it bounces like any other.

The method behind this template: How we write cold email sequences.

Dimitrije Jimmy Rešetar
About the authorDimitrije Jimmy Rešetar

Jimmy is the founder of Creatop, where he has built outbound systems for more than 30 B2B companies. He is a Sales Community Lead in the Apollo community and a member of the Apollo Headless Customer Advisory Board.

More templates

More on cold email

→

Learn from our work

Logo

OUR NEWSLETTER

Notes from live campaigns. No theory, no filler.

PAGES

SERVICES

MORE

LEGAL

Creatop

© 2026 Creatop. All rights reserved.

Learn from our work

Logo

OUR NEWSLETTER

Notes from live campaigns. No theory, no filler.

PAGES

SERVICES

MORE

LEGAL

Creatop

© 2026 Creatop. All rights reserved.

Learn from our work

Logo

OUR NEWSLETTER

Notes from live campaigns. No theory, no filler.

PAGES

SERVICES

MORE

LEGAL

Creatop

© 2026 Creatop. All rights reserved.